My story in tabletop RPGs
How it all started
Way back in 2014, a bunch of us subscribers were hanging out in the Chemodany chat on the newly created StopGame Discord server. Just sitting there, chilling, getting bored, talking hot air. One thing led to another, and we got talking about tabletop RPGs. I was completely clueless back then, but I had heard a thing or two about the Dungeons & Dragons universe, and I had played the first Neverwinter Nights obsessively around 2005. As often happens with things like D&D, Warhammer and the like — first comes a computer game, and then...
So there we are on the server, and one thing leads to another:
“I don't know what this is, but I really want to play D&D,” I say, voicing a thought that has just popped into my head.
“Oh, me too!” someone in the chat replies.
“That would be great,” someone else agrees.
“So why aren't we playing, then?” I ask.
“No GMs.”
“No problem,” I decide, and immediately make a deal with the others: don't beat me with sticks too hard, and I'll run a game for them. I take a look — the rulebook is three hundred and something pages, and there are several books. We agree that I'll get my head around the rules in a couple of weeks, and after that they can try not to kick me too hard.
And so the story of Nashmir began
I picked up fifth edition — the one from that very same year, 2014. In my spare time after work, I somehow read through it, put the characters together, and off we went. Paid GMs weren't quite so common back then, or maybe the whole idea was just very alien to me. I ran games “for our own little crowd,” but with all the imagination I could muster.
We started with Lost Mine of Phandelver — what else were we going to start with? But almost from the very first session, everything went off the rails, and it was great. Right at the start, I told the others they could build the world with me and fill it with whatever their imaginations came up with. That was the coolest thing about the game, and it also became its biggest ticking time bomb.
In those first few sessions, we came up with “forces of the soul,” or “sildu” — a sort of driving, nonmaterial essence operating at the elementary level and manifesting as emotions at the macroscopic level. From that grew the detailed mythology of Nashmir, which I'll gradually bring over here when I have the time.
The world kept filling out and changing the Faerûn familiar to so many people, because we didn't need Faerûn for our game. We thought it was cool to have “our world” — “Nashmir.” Within just a few sessions, gods had emerged from sildu as beings that fed on particular forces of the soul. The word “Warhammer” meant absolutely nothing to me at the time, and the idea is so straightforward that just about any kind of shamanism starts from something along those lines. When I got to know Warhammer lore later, I naturally recognised plenty of similarities. The first almost-god in our adventure was the Nothic living not far from the starting town. The rift there came in handy too: it later grew into the idea of the “Great Weaving,” which still bore a distant resemblance to the idea behind the game's original setting.
Players left, but more often, more and more arrived. And a year later, I found myself surrounded by brilliant people, for whom and with whom we had built a whole continent, given it meaning, and filled in its economic and political quirks. The players started digging further into the mystery of the conflict and the world's underlying premises, which I had thought through in depth over that time. They gained homebrew abilities and options that an experienced GM would have banned straight away. But the stories we told one another together — they were magnificent. They developed slowly, sometimes far too slowly (another trap a more experienced GM wouldn't have fallen into), but every character got a wonderful amount of development. Each had a deep motivation the other players understood and a long, coherent story.
A year in, I was running three or four games a week in the same world, all at the same point in the in-game timeline. The parties could cross paths and meet one another; one group's actions affected the state of the whole world. Some heroically overcame the odds; some died.
Once, we brought all the parties together on the same day, in the same place, in the same town, and everyone could talk. It was the most complicated game I've ever run. For the players, it was the strangest and most mixed experience. They played to a schedule: logging in and out, interacting with one another, then stepping out of the story. I definitely don't want to repeat that experience, but it was worth having. The parties stopped being abstract to one another and became real, specific people. They also had a chance to reshuffle and head off in different directions with new line-ups.
Not just GMing
I tried being a player too. Sometimes it worked out, but mostly it didn't. I learned plenty of painful lessons, even though I'd already been running games for quite a while. Things went wrong for all sorts of reasons. The worst time was when I was first invited to play Curse of Strahd. I knew nothing about the adventure then, and foolishly came up with a character who simply couldn't exist in such a grim world. Predictably, the whole party died in the very first dungeon. I got kicked out of the group, quite fairly.
The fall
The idyll couldn't last forever: Nashmir fell apart after about two years. There were plenty of reasons:
- multiple homebrew rules that were becoming harder and harder to keep track of;
- players who had come to see it as the GM's obligation to keep up with their ever-increasing level of expertise and their wishes for the game, especially compared with other GMs, including paid ones, who were becoming ever easier to find;
- a complicated, tangled story that I had collected into huge tomes of lore, which not everyone could access or found interesting;
- changes in real life: I had taken on a responsible position at work and a heap of family concerns;
- as a result of all that, an enormous shortage of time, too little sleep, and general, steadily mounting exhaustion;
- and the upshot of it all — conflicts at the gaming table and beyond it.
Under the weight of responsibility and the sheer amount of work, the GM burned out. First I took a couple of months off to try to pull myself together, but when I came back, it already felt like walking to my execution. The guy who had taken over as GM and I had agreed that he would cover some of my sessions for those few weeks. When I took the reins back, I made a move the players couldn't and wouldn't understand. I'd been building towards that idea for a long time, but over those couple of months the players had forgotten it, and I couldn't explain it properly or in time.
There was a conflict. A nasty, lightning-fast one. All the reasons I'd taken a break surfaced at once, and — I left Nashmir. Mutual accusations, hours of talking about who was to blame and who was right. That was the last straw, and those toxic relationships had to end. I gave the others everything I'd developed so they could carry on playing. Later I heard they had apparently seen it through to the end. I handed over control of the game on the platform we used and got out.
For several years, I physically couldn't return to either Discord or tabletop RPGs. As soon as I thought about it, my brain dumped such a cocktail of hormones into my bloodstream that moving in that direction became physically painful.
This time, a little wiser
A couple of years passed, and I found the strength to return to the Discord server and even talk to the others. It got a little easier. But the shock of the break had been so enormous that, fortunately or unfortunately, I never did start playing or socialising with them again. And I'm still not running games — there's no time to prepare. Turning out shoddy work isn't my style.
Just for fun, I ran a few wonderful games in person for my colleagues at work. Played with actual miniatures. Printed them. Tried painting them — not my thing, but it was fun.
Then I discovered all sorts of Discord servers that had flourished in the meantime. And it turned out there were GMs there who ran games professionally. That's where I met a grown-up woman who GMs. I was scrolling through announcement channels and spotted “age 30+.” My immediate thought: “Sign me up!” And I chose well.
I can't say I'm now a player with no bad habits or questionable behaviour at the table. We're all human, after all. I love roleplaying and a bit of theatre at the table, when characters get the spotlight and shine in it — whether it's my character or someone else's. I've hated metagaming with all my heart since my very first games. I love sessions full of social interaction between the players' characters, including the GM's. A lot of people find that boring — I do what I can to keep myself in check.
I even wrote a module for Foundry VTT, either for myself or against myself, after a more impatient player complained that I'd stolen the spotlight. The module may not have proved anything to anyone, but it did turn out to be quite useful to GMs in general. You can find it in the official repository and give it a go.
I'm a difficult player. Having seen so many patterns of bad behaviour at the table, I'm very sensitive to any hint of what causes them. I adore my characters and spend an enormous amount of time on every one of them: thinking through their motivations and dramatic arcs, preparing good scenes, and bringing an interesting thread of my own and my protégé's to our shared story. I like long campaigns and rarely play one-shots. The only exceptions are for my GM friends, whose abilities I trust.
If you're curious, you can have a look at my character concepts and drafts.
What this hobby has given me
Tabletop RPGs have been considered a pastime for geeks pretty much since they began. And I suppose that's fair. But thanks to this pastime, I've learned:
- to get along with people: I didn't get to learn that at school — I was bullied there, thanks in large part to the class teacher who allowed and encouraged it — so I had other things on my mind; in RPGs, that skill isn't just necessary, it gets plenty of practice;
- to find compromises in complicated situations and, when necessary, stand my ground;
- to give my imagination some structure and rein in its flights so they don't scatter too far;
- to find inspiration again to write poems and songs, and even prose, although with my failing grade in Russian (another sarcastic thank-you to that same teacher), that seems to be something I ought to avoid;
- to find a tremendous emotional outlet, when at least in my imagination I can give someone a kicking or do exactly “that thing you would have done if you'd been able to back then.”
I also became interested in 3D printing, which brought me back to modelling little parts in 3D after a long break stretching back to my university days.
What's next?
I'm continuing to develop my modules for Foundry VTT. Slowly, a little at a time, but the people I recommend them to say thank you.
I play with several GMs and lots of players, using different systems and different settings. I play for my own enjoyment. I have a blast. I recommend that everyone give this hobby a go. My characters.
At some point, I plan to work up the courage to pull together the various versions of my own RPG system and finish the setting. But that feels a bit like a stage I've already been through. At least until a sufficiently mature and distinctive idea comes along — one that doesn't just transplant fantasy's Middle Ages somewhere else yet again.